2025 MYSTERY DENIM

Update to respond: Yes, I know it says it may be any brand, but in the description it specifically says to use your normal JUDY BLUE sizing when ordering. Thats deceiving. And then to not honor an exchange for appropriate size isnt right. No, I have no interest in visiting the storefront unless you are exchanging my denim for a size I can actually wear.

I ordered the mystery denim, did the sizing exactly how they recommended (normal judy blue sizing). I only wear Judy Blues so i know my exact size. The jeans i got were not Judy Blue and dont even fit one leg. Plus they were white, and a lower rise. So, i dont recommend unless you know the brand and rise so you can size accordingly. Ive reached out by email to ask about exchange, but no response. I really wanted to love this boutique as im new to Magnolia, but this hasnt made me want to make the switch to them being my "go to" for shopping. I did order the mystery top as well. All the tops I got were good quality, but only one that I would actually wear. I would recommend that though, as personal preference doesnt mean bad. Its excellent quality. The denim was good quality as well, but definitely not Judy Blue nor was the sizing the same as Judy Blue. Maybe dont specify to order Judy Blue size if whats being sent isnt that brand or same sizing.

Emma Lou's does the best mystery deals! The jeans I got are ones I did not have yet and fit perfectly. Love their choice

Great Judy Blue jean but just a bit too baggy on me.

First time trying this brand and I was so in love with them that I ordered a 2nd pair. They are super cute and the fit is perfect.

I started shopping with Emma Lous Boutique I think about a year ago but maybe longer. I LOVE IT !!!! Tiffany and Paul are just delightful and the “lives” are so informative and fun. It didn’t take long to fall in love with their family, both personal and on-line shopping family !!! I’m always sad when I miss a live but I can always shop the replay but I miss the conversations with them and all the ladies. I’m just thrilled to be apart of the “family” and I know you will too once you spend time with us.

Great quality. Im just not used to their sizing, i went down 1 size and its still too big.

The mystery pair I received were cute but completely wrong fit/size. Fit like they were mis-sized from factory. Tag said they were my size and fit more like they were one to two sizes smaller. I typically wear 11/12 in multiple different brands, so I felt safe ordering this size. Did not even come close but that’s the risk you run ordering a mystery pair. Arrived quickly from date of ordering.

Love them more than any jeans I've ever owned!

Never again will I order mystery jeans! Not only did I get 2 pair thinking I was getting Judy blues I received a pair of capris and a brand I have never heard of and looks like they would fit a 12 year old girl. Then find out no returns! That’s bad business at least you could exchange. Very disappointing never again!

I know they were mystery, but I got two pairs with holes in them. I’m a 66-year-old woman. I guess I should’ve put that in there consideration

I received my Mystery Jeans and Top and they were Perfect!! I will be ordering again!!

I ordered size 3 because that is the size I wear in Judy Blue. The denim I got were not Judy Blue and size is too small. According to the return portal I am stuck with 2 pairs of jeans that are too small. Very disappointed!!

I did not like the big holes in the knee's, that is not me nor can I wear them to work. I would be nice when opting for a mystery gift we could say no holes.

I was so happy to get my package and it did not disappoint. ELB is amazing. I love shopping the store since I’m local. Everyone is so nice and they have an amazing selection. This was fun! Thank you!

I’ve always bought JB and I’ve never really considered any other brands. The brand sent and the fits selected were perfect for me. Very happy with the purchase.

I asked for non distressed and full length.
I got destressed cropped jeans. I am a teacher, so I cannot wear distressed jeans to school. Cropped jeans do not go well with 25 degree weather.

These are great. Never thought of getting white jeans, but they fit great and I love them.
Received them fast, even over the holidays

Oh my gosh!! They hit it out of the park. I would have not picked these out on my own. Im so glad I did the mystery Denim. I got Judy Blue high waist cargo boot cut. In love

Loved my denim! Would definitely do another mystery denim pack again!

I love mg jeans, they are great. So comfortable and soft.

Seriously!! The ugliest jeans I have ever seen. Will not wear them....thinking about displaying them in effigy warning others DO NOT BUY. Wanted to return them but could not find the return form anywhere on the website. Sent an email asking for help so I could get them returned in the 7 day window (they were delivered on a Saturday and next day was Sunday so really only 5 days). Never received any response so here I am stuck with "distressed" (ooh, I mean really distressed!) jeans that I am sure no one would want to buy even if they are Judy Blues! SO SO SO disappointed in the quality of the merchandise. PS: for the record I am a younger looking and smaller 76 year old and there is no way I would EVER be caught in those GOD AWFUL jeans. Also because it was delivered a weekend before New Years Eve and Day seems the return policy could have been extended somewhat. Oh but wait! There was no way I could find the return form to send them back. So frustrating!! Never again!
Marilyn Sparnicht

Perfect fit!

I ordered 2 pairs of Mystery Denim. I got one pair 1 pair of Judy Blue jeans and 1 pair of Lovervet by Vervet jeans. Unfortunately the Judy Blue ones were Long/Tall and I didn't buy the optional return option when ordering. I wish there was a length/inseam option when ordering. The Lovervet ones are awesome and I am happy to have a new brand of jeans I can wear.

I own several pairs of Judy blues the waist was 1 inch smaller than all of my other Judy blues. I reached out to customer service. It’s been a week and I haven’t heard anything ergo the unsatisfactory writing.

Love both!

I ordered 4 pairs of mystery jeans from Emma Lou's and absolutely fell in love with each pair. They fit me well and are some of the softest jeans I have ver owned. I love a good surprise so the mystery sales are right up my alley and it is definitely a GOOD surprise :)